Menu

Loot Boxes Will Be Investigated by FTC

Microtransactions and loot boxes are almost universally despised by the gaming community these days. Even so, most companies that take charge of popular multiplayer titles use them as a means of making the majority of their money. The morality and ethics behind this are choppy, especially when players run into paywalls, pay-to-win, and random-chance loot boxes, especially when all of these appear in the context of a game that already costs money. However, the days of random loot boxes may be numbered in the United States; the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has promised a thorough investigation of the practice that could potentially outlaw them from the entire industry.

The question remains: are there grounds for banning loot boxes nationally? I say, “absolutely,” but perhaps not in the way a lot of people think and perhaps not even in the way the FTC intends to investigate the situation. The argument floats around that loot boxes simply deceive the players into believing their chances of receiving something of significant value are higher than the truth. While studios and publishers certainly want you to believe that, the most this will probably advocate for are the chances being listed for each item or type of item the loot box could give you. China enacted a similar policy earlier this year which let the cats out of their bags for many games. The true way we may see a ban in the United States relates to a conversation from earlier this year involving the Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB).

It’s said that they considered (and still are considering) microtransactions and loot boxes effectively forcing a game into a mature rating. First of all, this would make the entire industry practically only for the ages of 17 and older. I doubt this will really go through, but the same premise could be used to wipe loot boxes clean off the state. The United States has strict gambling laws that prohibit people under the age of 18 from gambling; in some parts of the country, it even reaches 21. In other parts, certain types of sports gambling are banned altogether. Loot boxes closely resemble this idea of paying money for a chance at something possibly more valuable but usually less valuable.

Loot boxes arguably expose children and teenagers to gambling earlier than U.S. law intends. The FTC could decide that the mainstream appeal of video games – especially games like Fortnite – is unstoppable and that the most effective way to keep children from loot boxes is to disallow them. However, the beforementioned consideration by the ESRB could still serve as another option.

There are also questions surrounding what the industry will do in the event that loot boxes go away. Let the speculation begin! While loot boxes certainly get into some legal issues, microtransactions are here to stay, so companies will have that to bank on. However, I could see an evolution of the loot box coming out of this. This biggest issue is within the unknown chances and how they relate to kids. It will be interesting to see how the industry handles this.

No comments

Leave a Reply

Newsletter

Logo for Gamescom Opening Night Live on a purple background

Gamescom: Opening Night Live Round-Up

Gamescom: Opening Night Live just aired and there’s quite a bit to talk about. Hosted by the creator of the Game Awards Geoff Keighley, the stream featured a number of…

August 19, 2019, 62

Sony Interactive Entertainment Acquires Insomniac Games

[UPDATE] Further information has emerged concerning Sony’s acquisition of Insomniac Games. All of Insomniac’s owned non-Sony exclusive IP, which include Sunset Overdrive, Fuse, Song of the Deep, Edge of Nowhere, and…

August 19, 2019, 56
Promotional image showing off new games coming to xbox game pass

Gamescom: Inside Xbox Round-Up 08/19

Xbox kicks off its Gamescom 2019 with an Inside Xbox live conference, showing off some new footage for upcoming titles. Over the 40 minutes the stream ran for, a ton…

August 19, 2019, 53
Nintendo's Indi World Presentation Title Screen

Nintendo’s Indie World Round Up 8/19

Nintendo kicked off the Gamescom announcements this year with ‘Indie World’, a bite-sized Nintendo Direct style video to show off some of the best indie games heading to Switch later…

August 19, 2019, 84
Rainbow Road as seen in Mario Kart 8

Nine Tracks I’d like in Mario Kart 9

I’m a big fan of Mario Kart 8, and with Crash Bandicoot and Sonic getting racing games this summer, I can’t help but hope for a Mario Kart 9 on the horizon. In no…

August 16, 2019, 190
Gary Whitta

Halo 5 Writer Gary Whitta Announced as PAX West Keynote Speaker

Gary Whitta, writer for games like Telltale’s The Walking Dead, Halo 5: Guardians, and Prey and movies like Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, The Book of Eli, and After…

August 15, 2019, 108
Dead Island 2 Saints Row 5

Dead Island 2 Changes Developers, Saint’s Row V Coming Says THQ Nordic

THQ Nordic will be busy with some old series likely over the next couple of years. In a press release to investors, the company announced not only that development of…

August 14, 2019, 129
Title screen for Plants vs Zombies Battle for Neighborville

Plants Vs. Zombies Battle for Neighborville Trailer Leak + Switch Version Rumored

Man, what is it with Plants vs Zombies and leaks? Last week, screenshots of a new PvZ game were leaked, then a few days later the official title of the…

August 13, 2019, 243
Image taken taken from the PDF guide for the trial version of Shenmue III. It depicts main character Ryo Hazuki talkking to a woman whilst there are button prompts on-screen

Shenmue III Trial Version Coming in September

Shenmue III is soon to get a trial version, as announced by the official website. This trial is coming to PC via the Epic Games Store in the second half of…

August 13, 2019, 135
Detroit Become Human Roof Scene

Blaming Violence on Video Games Promotes Ignorance

El Paso, Texas and Dayton, Ohio in the U.S. have been the subjects of a lot of conversation after the August 3 and August 4 shootings, respectively. These shootings left a…

August 12, 2019, 153