Metacritic’s 36-hour User Review Policy Fights Review Bombing

Recently, review bombing games has become a common practice for people upset with the developers or publishers’ business practices and decisions. It seems Metacritic has taken action to prevent this by giving a 36-hour period between the release of games and the moment users have a chance to put up reviews. This was largely discovered when the user reviews for Ghost of Tsushima were found to be replaced by a message stating, “Please spend some time playing the game. Come back to review it starting at 12:00pm PST on July 18.”


The most recent victim of review bombing The Last of Us Part II. After leaks of a bulk of the game’s story several months ago, users were quick to flood the Metacritic user reviews for the game with negative feedback, known as review bombing, as a response to their disagreement with Naughty Dog’s direction for the game. Borderlands 2 also recently received review bombs on Steam when it was announced that Borderlands 3 would release on Epic Games Store well before it released on Steam.


These are just the most recent cases. However, it’s worth noting that according to a spokesperson from Metacritic, This decision was not made in response to review bombs or hasty feedback on any one game. “This new waiting period for user reviews… was based on data-driven research and with the input of critics and industry experts.” While this may be the case, it’s hard to believe that The Last of Us Part II didn’t have anything to do with it.


While this certainly takes action to hopefully prevent people from reviewing games too soon, the Borderlands 2 example has to do with review bombing a developer’s old game in response to news about a recent game. At the time, Steam took measures to ensure that Borderlands 2’s scores were rectified, but preventative measures have not yet been seen. Another similar scenario in the future could potentially spark more action on this side of the coin, but until then, this is a great step in the right direction for Metacritic.


No comments

Leave a Reply


This is The Zodiac Speaking Review – Colin Fry

**SPOILER/CONTENT ALERT! Plot elements of This is the Zodiac Speaking will be discussed here for the sake of critique. It also includes a description of the death of a young…

October 28, 2020, 206

Democracy 4 First Impressions – Early Access

A lot of political simulators find ways to take the insanity of the government and condense it down into easy-to-digest, overly simplistic casual games that don’t force the player to…

October 26, 2020, 932

GORSD Review – Garth Offered Red Slippers, Dope

“I hate that clown, but not as much as Mr. Far. I think I’ll go smoke a cigar.”   When it comes to learning a new skill, being thrown into…

October 15, 2020, 10,948
No Place for Bravery Interview

Developer Dialogue: No Place for Bravery Interview @ PAX Online

There were plenty of unique and exciting games at PAX Online this year. One that stood out to me the most was No Place for Bravery, an action RPG from…

October 4, 2020, 12,654
Promotional image for the Super Smash Bros Ultimate/Minecraft crossover, shows four Minecraft characters standing in front of prospective Smash stages

Steve and Alex From Minecraft Join Super Smash Bros Ultimate

October has hit the ground running with this morning’s announcement that the latest downloadable characters for Super Smash Bros. Ultimate are… Steve and Alex from Minecraft! Nintendo have repeatedly smashed expectations with regards…

October 1, 2020, 12,819

Bounty Battle Review – Ultra Mash Brothaz

“I was walking on the ground, I didn’t make a sound. Then, I turned around, and I saw a clown.”   When it comes to fighting games, it’s always the…

September 28, 2020, 12,664
Gameplay still from 30XX displaying protagonist character Ace dodging enemy fire

Developer Dialogue: 30XX Interview @ PAX Online

Time after time, indie developers have struck gold modernizing the retro archetypes that AAA studios won’t touch. It’s not just a shrewd way to maximize limited resources; it’s also a…

September 24, 2020, 12,776
Gameplay still from Nier Replicant showing a suspended steampunk styled bridge

Nier Replicant Remastered Releases April 2021

With Nier: Automata raising the franchise’s profile immensely, it only makes sense that its predecessor would gain a second life. Square Enix is turning this wish into a reality with the impending…

September 24, 2020, 12,630

Crysis Remastered Review – Mid-Life

“Picture this, if I could make the change, I’d love to pull the wires from the wall. Did you?”   Truth be told, I’ve never owned a PC built specifically…

September 22, 2020, 12,714
Promotional image for Microsoft's acquisition of Bethesda, shows Bethesda IPs Elder Scrolls, Fallout, Doom, etc standing in a row

Microsoft Acquires Bethesda Parent Company for $7.5 Billion

Just one day before Xbox Series X and Xbox Series S preorders open, Microsoft have announced a game-changing acquisition. For $7.5 billion, Microsoft has entered into an agreement to acquire…

September 21, 2020, 12,666